Cheetah: The biggest thing about Firey going was it created chaos all over. Should we keep going with that trajectory?
Chase: Who are you suggesting?
Cheetah: Copycat.
Chase: I want to keep Copycat around as a shield. I really think if we murder Tracker, that will make people even more sus of Copycat and they won’t look at us at all.
Mayor Humdinger: The thing is, we also have to consider strength for the challenges. Sweetie really bombed it for our team. We could’ve had $10,000 in the pot had it not been for her.
Cheetah: Strategically, I’m more on your side, Chase. For the challenges, I’m on Mayor Humdinger’s side for that one.
Chase: I do agree with Mayor Humdinger about Sweetie being a weak competitor.
Mayor Humdinger: And I agree with you too about how murdering Tracker would obviously put a target on Copycat.
Chase: So it’s gotta be either Tracker, Copycat, or Sweetie.
Later…
Chase: You guys sure about this one?
Cheetah: I’m sure.
Chase writes a name on the murder letter.
The traitors seal the murder letter and give it to Alan and leave the turret.
The next morning…
Alan: And so, the traitors have chosen their second victim to murder. Surviving players will make their way to breakfast. And one player will have been eliminated. And only the traitors know who that is.
The door opens. Chase, Cheetah, Everest, and Skye enter for breakfast.
Chase: Oh, we’re the first ones in.
Cheetah, Traitor
Cheetah(confessional): It was a perfect scenario for me walking in first with Chase. Not a lot of eyes are on us traitors, but we know who’s walking through the door. And I know one thing for sure. This murder, it’s gonna be big.
Skye: We evaded being murdered once again.
Chase: We survived another night. How are you feeling?
Cheetah: Still on edge, like, nervous, ‘cause I don’t know who’s gonna walk through the door.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): I have no problem sitting back and trying to maintain that shocked appearance. I can’t give away for one second who it may or may not be.
Chase: After the first roundtable, it can go in so many different ways. A lot of people voiced their opinions.
The door opens. Leafy, Marshall, Ryder, and Sid enter for breakfast.
Leafy, BFDI Contestant
Leafy(confessional): Any day I’m walking to breakfast alive is a relief.
Marshall: Moving forward, we have to get a traitor out tonight. We have to get a traitor.
Everest: Otherwise, we’re all screwed.
Marshall: I think it’s really important that we gather information today.
Everest: The only person that’s gonna get rid of faithfuls is a traitor. Copycat sent Rubble home. And he was confident, and he was wrong. If he’s not a traitor, then he’s the worst faithful ever.
The door opens. Arrby and Harold enter for breakfast.
Arrby, Sid’s Pup
Arrby(confessional): I’m just really grateful that I’m still here because I‘m the quietest person in this house. But it might actually carry me a few days into this game. I just lay low and let people make themselves targets.
The door opens. Copycat and Mayor Humdinger enter for breakfast.
Copycat, Supervillain
Copycat(confessional): I survived the banishment, I survived the murder. And so my game plan today is just to sit back, be quiet, just take everything in. I’m not gonna say a word.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): Copycat would have been a good one to murder and put targets on other people’s back. But as traitors, we didn’t want to create a predictable pattern. He is now an easy target for the other faithfuls.
The door opens. Duke, Rocky, and Zuma enter for breakfast.
Rocky: I thought I was dead.
Knocking is heard on the door.
The door opens. Ladybird enters for breakfast.
Leafy: There’s just two left. It’s Tracker or Sweetie.
Leafy, BFDI Contestant
Leafy(confessional): Tracker and Sweetie are two of the lesser known hero and villain, so I’m a bit shocked it’s between them.
Leafy: These traitors are murdering all the quiet people.
Knocking is heard at the door.
Leafy: Come in.
The door opens. Tracker enters for breakfast.
Cheetah: Oh my god
Ladybird: Sweetie’s gone.
Tracker: Sweetie’s out?
Last Night
Mayor Humdinger: The thing is, we also have to consider strength for the challenges. Sweetie really bombed it for our team. We could’ve had $10,000 in the pot had it not been for her.
Chase: I think it’ll send a message that they need to bring their best to these challenges or else they can fall victim to murder.
Cheetah: That’s the move we gotta do.
Chase writes Sweetie's name on the murder letter.
The traitors seal the murder letter and give it to Alan and leave the turret.
In the confessional booth…
Sweetie enters the confessional booth.
Sweetie opens the letter and reads it.
Sweetie: Dear Sweetie, by order of the traitors, you have been murdered. Signed, the traitors.
Sweetie: If it’s for personal reasons, Duke or Chase did this. If it’s for challenges, it’s Mayor Humdinger, Duke, or Harold. I feel like Duke definitely murdered me.
Flashback End
Alan enters the room.
Alan: Good morning. I hope you managed to get a good night’s sleep. Although I imagine it must be rather tricky when you know you may not see the light of day. As you see, this place is less bed and breakfast, more deathbed and breakfast. And I am much less Agatha Christie in a fabulous outfit. But why are you laughing? A royal pup was murdered last night.
Alan takes Sweetie’s portrait off the wall.
Alan: Sweetie, won’t get the crown Scotland. She’ll have to try again in Barkingburg Castle.
Alan throws Sweetie’s portrait to the side.
Alan: 3 down, 17 to go, but everything to play for. And talking of play, I’ll meet you outside in a few minutes to explain the rules of today’s mission.
Later…
Ladybird: Who would murder Sweetie?
Leafy: I think it would be Chase or Duke. Duke, I think, would want to murder Sweetie as more of a personal move. Chase, same thing, but also Sweetie's just bad at challenges.
Ladybird: Yeah, I see that too.
Leafy, BFDI Contestant
Leafy(confessional): I think Duke’s a straight shooter, and I wouldn’t be shocked that if he’s a traitor he would take the direct shot at Sweetie or Skye.
In another room…
Skye: It’s gotta be Duke.
Chase: Yeah, I agree.
Skye: He’s definitely murdering me next if we don’t banish him tonight.
Chase: You think so?
Skye: Duke is definitely a traitor, and if we don’t banish him, he could murder me.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): Skye, it wasn’t Duke, it was me. But, I need to get Duke banished at this next roundtable because if he survives and Skye’s not murdered, it might make people less suspicious of him.
Later…
Duke of Flappington, The Duke of Flappington
Duke(confessional): I’m happy Sweetie is gone, but I’m definitely worried that people will suspect me of being a traitor and think I murdered her.
Duke: Maybe they tried to set me up.
Mayor Humdinger: I don’t know.
Outside…
Everyone meets Alan outside.
Alan: Hello there.
Cast: Hello.
Alan: Music gives a soul to the universe and life to everything. Music could also give you 25 grand today. to add to the already existing 45 grand in your prize pot. Today’s task is quite simply to make sweet, sweet music. You’ll all have to pull together to achieve your goal. In your last mission, you left money on the table. So how will today’s mission go? And who will be culpable if there’s a failure? It’s time to split up into two groups. The first group of seven will be the music makers. The other group of 10, your job is to be the ears.
They divide themselves into two groups.
Skye: Rubble could’ve been a good music maker if we didn’t banish him last night.
Tracker: I want to be an ear.
Music Makers: Harold, Duke, Cheetah, Leafy, Ryder, Rocky, Zuma
Ears: Tracker, Everest, Chase, Skye, Ladybird, Marshall, Mayor Humdinger, Copycat, Arrby, Sid
Alan: So, for the music makers, you’ll be taking a short walk to the castle chapel. Once there, you will take turns in conducting a masterpiece for the rest of the group to play on the magnificent chapel bells, all under the watchful eye of my groundskeeper, Fergus. The rest of you, the listeners, will join me in the castle. Your task is to match the music coming from the bells to the music contained in a music box from my extensive collection in the castle. There is a figurine in every music box. Once you have matched the music coming from the bells to the music in the music box, you must search the castle for an item that matches the figurine and bring it to me. There will be 5 rounds, 5 minutes each, and for every correct item you bring me, I will give you $5,000 to add to the collective prize pot.
Cast: (cheers)
Alan: Music makers, you will now take the short walk to the chapel. Ears, follow me.
Cheetah, Traitor
Cheetah(confessional): I’ll definitely be watching everybody during this mission to see if there’s any clear-cut people we can murder from something that happens during the mission.
In the chapel…
The music makers enter the chapel.
Harold, Mayor Humdinger’s Nephew
Harold(confessional): My music has forced people to dance, if that’s not impressive, what is?
Alan: Players, the game has started.
Rocky: Okay. 1, 4, 4…
Alan: While the bells are being rung, it’s up to the rest of the players to decipher the tune.
Rocky: Oh, shoot. I’m sorry, I messed that up.
Leafy: Is that the New Year’s Eve song?
Cheetah: Maybe you’re right.
Rocky: 5, 4, 5, 6, 5.
Outside…
Alan: Do you know what the song is?
Chase: I know.
Everyone races to find the figurine.
Everest: What is it?
Chase: It’s Auld Lang Syne.
Tracker: What’s the figurine?
Everest: We don’t know what the figurine is yet.
Everyone listens to each music box to find the song.
Alan: 3 minutes has elapsed.
Marshall: It’s this one. This is Auld Lang Syne.
Chase: Owl. It’s in the billiard room.
Chase goes to the billiard room.
Alan: Hurry, players. Clock is ticking.
Chase takes the owl and gives it to Alan.
Chase: Correct.
Ears: (cheers)
In the chapel…
Fergus rings the Pass bell.
Music Makers: (cheers)
Cheetah, Traitor
Cheetah(confessional): As a traitor, it’s all about the money. I want our “team,” as faithfuls to win as much money as possible so the traitors and I can steal it at the end.
Back in the castle…
Alan: $5,000. Don’t get too cocky. It’s time for the next round.
In the chapel…
Ryder: Okay, so, 6, 2, 3, 4, 5.
Outside…
Ladybird: Oh, I know what it is.
Everyone races to find the figurine.
Marshall: You know what it is?
Ladybird: It’s that piano song.
Alan: Your time’s halfway up. 2 and a half minutes.
Everyone listens to each music box to find the song.
Alan: 2 minutes remaining, players.
Arrby: It’s this one. Ballet slippers.
Alan: You only have 20 seconds remaining.
Marshall find the ballet slippers and gives it to Alan.
Alan: Congratulations.
Ears: (cheers)
Alan: Just in the nick of time, but congratulations. $10,000 have been won.
In the chapel…
Fergus rings the Pass bell.
Music Makers: (cheers)
Leafy, BFDI Contestant
Leafy(confessional): Yes, we got this money! Money in the bank.
Duke: Here we go. Alright, 8, 6, 7, 7, 5, 6.
Outside…
Chase: Is that The Nutcracker?
Everyone races to find the figurine.
Everyone listens to each music box to find the song.
Tracker: It’s the top hat.
Everest finds the top hat and gives it to Alan.
Alan: Congratulations.
Ears: (cheers)
Alan: Another $5,000 to the prize pot.
In the chapel…
Fergus rings the Pass bell.
Music Makers: (cheers)
Leafy: 6, 7, 8…
Outside…
Ladybird: Ode to Joy.
Everyone races to find the figurine.
Everyone listens to each music box to find the box.
Sid: This is it. The feather.
Arrby: This?
Arrby finds the feather and gives it to Alan.
Ears: (cheers)
In the chapel…
Fergus rings the Pass bell.
Music Makers: (cheers)
Back in the castle…
Alan: $20,000 you’ve made for the team. Bravo. You’re on a roll.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): 20 Gs, we’re doing a great job.
In the chapel…
Harold: Okay, so, 3, 3, 5…
Outside…
Chase: That’s Rockabye, Baby.
Everyone races to find the figurine.
Tracker: Which one’s Rockabye, Baby?
Everest: Chase is absolutely killing this mission.
Everyone listens to each music box to find the box.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): If you do well at a mission. I do think that it will make people feel comfortable and trust me. And I’m trying to get as much safety and support as I can.
Chase: It’s right here. It’s a horse and a carriage.
Skye: Get it! Get it!
Chase finds the horse and carriage and gives it to Alan.
Alan: Well done.
Ears: (cheers)
In the chapel…
Fergus rings the Pass bell.
Music Makers: (cheers)
Back in the castle…
Alan: $25,000. Congratulations. Working together has really paid off.
Later…
Ryder: The mission of the day is accomplished, but mine’s still going. I just want to find the traitors.
Rocky: Me too.
Tracker: Even though Duke is under a lot of suspicion, I’m still thinking Copycat is the traitor. He’s really sneaky.
Rocky: I agree.
Skye, Aviation/Flying Pup
Skye(confessional): Some of the other pups still want to go for Copycat, and he’s still on my radar, but Duke has got to go first. If we don’t get him out, he’s going to murder me.
Later…
Leafy: So, let’s talk about who we’re getting rid of, because it’s gonna happen tonight. Again.
Tracker: I would only choose someone who was sending other faithfuls home, because you took up a chance for us to send a traitor home.
Copycat: Tracker, I know you’re talking about me. Do you still think I'm a traitor?
Tracker: You sent Rubble home when we should be sending traitors home.
Copycat: That was a misread, that was not intentional.
Tracker: That was intentional. Don’t lie.
In another room…
Skye, Aviation/Flying Pup
Skye(confessional): Everest and I have an idea who the traitors are. But it’s really hard to talk around other people. So we thought, “Let’s write it down and sort this out.”
Skye: Let’s name, like, who we’re not sure of.
Everest: Sid?
Skye: Nah, I don’t think so.
Skye crosses Sid’s name out on the paper.
Everest: Ladybird?
Skye: Maybe.
Everest: But definitely Duke and Copycat.
Skye: Duke and Copycat are for sure traitors, but my plan is to get Duke out tonight. He is 100% a traitor.
Everyone gathers for the roundtable.
Alan: Hello, players. What a busy and lucrative day you’ve had. You raised $25,000. The collective prize pot now stands at $70,000. But if a traitor remains at the end of the game, they’ll take it all. Now is the time to draw that evil like poison from a wound and banish a traitor forever from the game. You all have one vote. And the player who receives the most votes, be they faithful or traitor, will leave the game immediately.
Ryder: I will speak up as a faithful. It’s been a weird murder pattern, Firey then Sweetie. Not really major people from each side. Firey, I have no idea. But for Sweetie, Duke, you would probably be someone who would murder Sweetie.
Duke: If I was a traitor, maybe I would. But it wasn’t me that did it.
Skye: Who else would do it?
Duke: I think you or Chase.
Skye: Me? Why would I murder Sweetie?
Duke: To frame me.
Skye: If I was a traitor and I wanted you out, I would just murder you.
Duke: You thought that would be too obvious, so you murdered her to put the blame on me.
Skye: Or maybe you murdered her and tried to make it look like you were set up.
Tracker: I also want to point another thing out today. Copycat, last roundtable, you went really hard for Rubble, and he was a faithful. You wasted the banishment for us faithfuls and helped out the traitors.
Copycat: It was a mistake, I wasn’t intentionally trying to do that.
Tracker: That was definitely intentional.
Copycat: I was trying to get Rubble banished, but I really thought he was a traitor.
Rocky: I also want to point out that Copycat, you can be strategic. The murders so far are Firey and Sweetie, and you’re probably someone with more strategic thought to murder them.
Copycat: Am I really that strategic?
Rocky: You know you’re an obvious traitor, and you’re trying to confuse the faithfuls.
Copycat: You’re trying to confuse them by getting me out. You’re dead set on me being a traitor.
Tracker: Because you are.
Leafy: I think the matter is, this is going to divulge into chaos.
Duke: I think it’s Skye.
Alan: The time for talk is over. It’s now the time to vote.
Everyone votes.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): It is very tense tonight. My name didn’t come up, so now I’m just gonna stay quiet and lay low as a Traitor.
Alan: Players, it’s time to reveal your votes. I’m going to start with you, Copycat.
Copycat reveals his vote. He voted for Duke.
Copycat: I voted for Duke. I feel like the murder really puts a target on your back, and I’m going along with it. If you're not banished, it’s gonna be me, so I hope you get banished.
Alan: Mayor Humdinger.
Mayor Humdinger reveals his vote. He voted for Skye.
Mayor Humdinger: Skye, I think you’re clever enough to pull off a plan like that.
Alan: Tracker.
Tracker reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Tracker: Um, Copycat.
Alan: Zuma.
Zuma reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Zuma: Copycat, I voted for you.
Alan: Ryder.
Ryder reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Ryder: Copycat. I‘m just strictly going off the people I really trust in this group.
Alan: We have 3 for Copycat, 1 for Duke, 1 for Skye. Sid.
Sid reveals his vote. He voted for Duke.
Sid: Duke, I voted for you. I got it wrong yesterday, and I don’t have much other suspicion that I feel I can actually go off of.
Alan: Marshall.
Marshall reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Marshall: Copycat, you caused a lot of chaos yesterday.
Alan: Everest.
Everest reveals her vote. She voted for Duke.
Everest: Duke, I voted for you.
Alan: Duke.
Duke reveals his vote. He voted for Skye.
Duke: I voted for you, Skye. I really believe you’re a traitor and you set me up.
Alan: Now we have 4 for Copycat, 3 for Duke, and 2 for Skye. Rocky.
Rocky reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Rocky: Copycat, I voted for you. There was never a second where I didn’t think you were a traitor.
Alan: Chase.
Chase: I listened to a lot of conversations today, and I was questioning my gut feelings. If I’m wrong, then I’ll eat that…
Chase reveals his vote. He voted for Duke.
Chase: But I had to vote Duke.
Alan: Arrby.
Arrby reveals his vote. He voted for Duke.
Arrby: I voted for you, Duke. After listening to what was said here at the roundtable, I voted for you.
Alan: So that’s 5 votes for Copycat, 5 for Duke, and 2 votes for Skye. Harold.
Harold reveals his vote. He voted for Copycat.
Harold: Copycat, I chose you because I believe you’re a traitor.
Alan: Skye.
Skye reveals her vote. She voted for Duke.
Skye: Duke, I voted for you. I am certain that you are a traitor.
Alan: Copycat has 6 votes, Duke has 6, Skye has 2. Leafy.
Leafy reveals her vote. She voted for Duke.
Leafy: Duke, I voted for you.
Alan: Cheetah.
Cheetah reveals her vote. She voted for Copycat.
Cheetah: Copycat.
Alan: This is it, the final vote. Copycat has 7, Duke has 7. Ladybird, your vote is crucial.
Ladybird: I don’t really know. I just went with this.
Ladybird reveals her vote. She voted for Duke.
Ladybird: I went with Duke.
Alan: Duke, you have received the most votes, and you are banished from the game. Please come and stand in the Circle of Truth.
Duke stands up and stands in the Circle of Truth.
Alan: Before you leave us, Duke, please reveal if you are a faithful or a traitor.
Duke: I feel like you guys went to conclusions already accusing me because of Sweetie’s murder, and thought I was a traitor…
Duke: But you’re wrong, I’m a Faithful. The Traitors are really good, they’re manipulating the heck out of you. Skye played you all hard.
Duke leaves the castle.
Copycat, Supervillain
Copycat(confessional): I am very relieved right now. By the skin of my teeth, I’m still here, but Duke was a faithful, so I don’t know what’s gonna come my way.
Alan: So, Duke was a faithful. Can you all wash the blood clean from your hands and find out who the traitors really are? Only time will tell. Sweet dreams.
Alan leaves.
Chase: Guys, we’re playing terribly. We just sent another faithful home.
Chase, Traitor
Chase(confessional): I couldn’t be happier. Another faithful bites the dust.
Tracker(whispers to Everest): I really think we have to vote Copycat tomorrow.
Everest(whispers to Tracker): Okay, you think Copycat?
Tracker(whispers to Everest): Let’s figure it out, it’s two days in a row.
Harold, Mayor Humdinger’s Nephew
Harold(confessional): We’re sitting at the roundtable, and as we’re talking. Skye gets up, and something falls out of her pocket. And I immediately fly off my stool, grab it, and I don’t say a word to anybody. So I go to the restroom. I open the note. “Sid, murder”, and that’s crossed out, and then Ladybird’s name.
Harold: Skye’s a traitor. I need to show this to somebody.
Later…
Harold: Look, this is from Skye. It says who they're murdering tonight.
Mayor Humdinger: Interesting.
Harold: Skye must be a traitor. I know it.
Mayor Humdinger: Yeah.
Mayor Humdinger, Traitor
Mayor Humdinger(confessional): This plays right into my hand. This is an opportunity to frame Skye. And I can’t wait for it.